Scott Atwater Outboard 5hp Bail-A-Matic Flywheel Recoil Catch Teeth Top 1946 85hp I would recommend that you

I would recommend that you replace it

but with different part numbers even though they might be the same part

so hopefully there are enough pictures here to help you identify the part and determine compatibility

Should work on multiple years please ask if unsure

Scott Atwater Outboard 5hp Bail-A-Matic Flywheel Recoil Catch Teeth Top 1946 85hp I would recommend that youItem Details This is off a 1956 Scott Atwater 5hp. Model # 37654723 Will work on multiple years. Good condition. Teeth look to be in working order. You get what is in the pictures. Inspect pictures closely for condition. May need a little cleaning. If you are unsure if this will fit you application please ask before purchasing. Yours should look like this one. Purchase with confidence! Please Contact Me if you have additional questions.